The following unabridged reviews are made available under license from their respective rights holders and publishers. Reviews may be used for educational purposes consistent with the fair use doctrine in your jurisdiction, and may not be reproduced or repurposed without permission from the rights holders.

Note: This section may include reviews for related titles (e.g., same author, series, or related edition).

From School Library Journal

Starred review from January 1, 2023

PreS-Gr 1-This book is a meditation on gratitude, full of intricate symbolism. Frazee explains in a note that she was inspired by a "call-and-response version of a Jewish baby-naming blessing" she heard at a Christian church decades ago. The text is made up of seven lines, all but the last composed of seven words each. Seven is a significant number in Judaism, and structuring the text in this way is a subtle acknowledgement of that faith tradition. Each of the seven lines is presented on a spread with a series of small illustrations, vignettes that represent each idea. Following each is a wordless spread featuring a sprawling landscape peopled by small figures. Each line has a thematic color, and the palettes of the wordless spreads combine the colors to link the concepts. The pages of the first line, "In every birth, blessed is the wonder," are suffused with a soft pink. The following spread shows a family gazing at the sky, a baby pointing to the fluffy pink clouds that slowly bleed into yellow, the color of the second line: "In every smile, blessed is the light." The overall mood is slow, steady, and soothing. The combination of the spiritual words and the prosaic moments alternating with grand panoramas bestows a magnitude to the minutiae of the everyday. The characters are diverse in every sense of the word, representing a myriad of families and lived experiences. While the book's brevity is appropriate for a read-aloud, children will want to examine the illustrations closely. VERDICT Simultaneously simple and majestic, this benediction of a book is recommended for first purchase.-Elizabeth Lovsin

Copyright 2023 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

From Horn Book

January 1, 2023
In her latest picture book, Frazee says she "hoped to capture and honor what we all have in common, no matter who we are or where we live." Each line of text begins with "In every..." and appears on its own spread with Frazee's signature pencil and gouache vignettes of people, young and old, epitomizing the sentiment expressed (� la her layouts for the similarly inspirational Everywhere Babies, rev. 5/01, and All the World, rev. 9/09). While the text is earnest, Frazee finds ways to insert light humor into her illustrations, such as a child using the potty for "In every hope, blessed is the doing." Wordless full-bleed spreads are interspersed between the vignette pages, showing wide landscape views with people finding peace and joy in nature; these offer viewers a chance to pause and reflect on that line's meaning. She also chooses a predominant color for each line's font and its accompanying art to aid young listeners in linking them together (e.g., yellow is the color associated with the line "In every smile, blessed is the light"). The affectionate domestic scenes feature a diverse mix of people and are a visual testament to Frazee's inclusive goal of showcasing the commonalities "in every life." According to her author's note, she's revised a baby-naming blessing that she attributes to the Jewish faith (the original source of which is unknown, "but it has been adapted and used widely in welcoming ceremonies of all kinds") by simplifying the poem and adding her own lines, including passages about smiles and sadness.

(Copyright 2023 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)

From Publisher's Weekly

Starred review from December 19, 2022
This brief, stirring benediction-based on a "call-and-response version of a Jewish baby-naming blessing," Frazee (The Great Zapfino) notes on the book's dedication page-starts with new life. "In every birth,/ blessed is the wonder" reads hand-lettered text, shown above delicately drawn vignettes of variously aged caregivers cuddling, nursing, and admiring infants and toddlers. "In every smile,/ blessed is the light" captures moments of pleasure as people read, talk, snuggle, and tussle. Across the pages' silvery vignettes, intersectionally inclusive groups and individuals experience anticipation ("In every hope/ blessed is the doing") and loss ("In every sadness,/ blessed is the comfort"), and embrace each other in vulnerability ("In every love,/ blessed are the tears"). Throughout, the blessings and attendant spot art alternate with wide, wordless landscapes: a changing sky covered in puffy pink clouds, a winding path through sparsely wooded hills, a lighted window on a rainy night. A rich trove of moving images lets Frazee range over an expansive constellation of human experiences, offering fodder to explore and discuss. Ages up to 8. Agent: Steven Malk, Writers House.

From Kirkus

Starred review from November 15, 2022
"And in every life, / blessed is the love." Frazee's author's note explains that she was inspired to write this text when she "heard a call-and-response version of a Jewish baby-naming blessing and immediately felt its potential as a picture book." After several false starts, she began working on it in 2020, "when so many things about our world were upended," and the following year, her first grandchild was born. In its inclusive, warmhearted celebration of community, family, and life itself, the resulting book feels like a melding of earlier titles Frazee illustrated: Everywhere Babies (2001) by Susan Meyers and All the World (2009) by Liz Garton Scanlon. While the realistic art style is akin to that of those books, the text is sparer, with pacing grounded in the call-and-response inspiration: "In every birth," reads the opening verso, with the resolution on the facing page reading, "blessed is the wonder." Accompanying vignettes of babies cared for by young and old people alike invite readers to speculate about relationships and to delight in the loving, diverse depictions. Then the page turn reveals a full-bleed vista of a couple with a baby looking at the sunrise, pink clouds filling the sky. Once established, this pattern--of a call-and-response spread illustrated with vignettes followed by a wordless full-bleed spread of a single family in nature--carries through the entire book, providing opportunities for observation, conversation, and reflection. (This book was reviewed digitally.) This lyrical blessing of a picture book belongs on every shelf. (Picture book. 3-6)

COPYRIGHT(2022) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.